Global Warming | Climate Change

The politicisation of the climate debate

Why global warming is not as divisive as it seems

Published April 2023 | Revised Nov 2023

Our politics, like other facets of society, is replete with a range of characters: the wise, the smart, the cunning, the egotistical, the opportunistic, and the absolutely ineffective politicians. This diversity is an intrinsic part of the democratic system, which many of us have embraced. However, it's important to note that these archetypes are not exclusive to democracy; they exist in authoritarian, monarchical, and other systems of governance as well. This phenomenon is a facet of the human condition, not a deficiency inherent to any specific form of government.

It's a universal truth: a bell curve that encompasses our wisest individuals and the absolute nonentities under the same societal roof. These archetypes are familiar; we recognize them, and at points in our lives, we might have embodied one or more of these roles, whether we admit it or not. We all navigate the continuum stretching from altruistic service to humanity at one end, to the pursuit of self-interest at the other. This is not about casting blame but about showcasing the human condition in its diverse forms.

Our most insightful leaders understand that global warming transcends partisan politics. The less wise may attempt to use it as a tool for personal advancement, exploiting our collective concerns. It's time to remove global warming from the list of divisive topics. Here’s why global warming should be viewed as a collective, non-partisan challenge, requiring unified action across the political spectrum instead of the divisive issue it is often presented as.

Global warming will affect us all

Sea level rises are poised to decimate our coastal towns, pushing populations further inland. Within a decade, mortgage brokers and insurance companies will likely make climate change impacts central to their assessments of home values. This shift means the poor will face the loss of villages and livestock, while the wealthy will see the value of their beachfront properties and assets plummet.

Global warming acts as an equal opportunities destroyer, meting out its destructive impacts across society irrespective of age, gender, religion, or political affiliation. Its primary target is our climate, but in the process, everyone gets affected. People from all political backgrounds, including generations X, Y, and Z, will feel its severe effects. Critical sectors like agriculture (crop yields), transportation, defense, healthcare, and societal cohesion are all in its firing line.

The politicisation is opportunistic

I once asked a friend to name a politician with caustic opinions on climate change who was not running for office, and he struggled. While some may name a few, the crux of the matter is this: many politicians, particularly those less effective, surf waves of public opinion for electoral success. Global warming, with its technical arguments and complex data, has become a favorite topic.

These politicians exploit our busy lives, knowing we can't fact-check every statement they make. They manipulate data, discredit reputable institutions and established science, then bombard us with drama and information overload. As a result, many of us tune out or capitulate. Those who capitulate form their voter base, while the rest are often ignored.

This opportunistic politicisation is amplified by our media and creates an impression that the issue is divisive when it has simply been hijacked by politicians seeking viral coverage. We contributed to this mess too. A politician stating that global warming is a hoax seems to garner more of our attention than the hundreds of politicians, policymakers and academics who are actually working methodically on the issue.

The division is inflated

The majority of people worldwide use basic thinking and decision-making processes that align more with unity than division, especially regarding global warming. We exhibit trust in institutions: we send our children to schools we trust, consult doctors for health advice, and even big pharma benefits from our patronage with homes full of medications. The widespread acceptance of Covid-19 vaccines, despite initial debates, is a testament to this trust. So, it begs the question: why would doubts about global warming gain significant traction? The truth is, while most people do not seriously entertain these doubts, there is a vested interest in perpetuating the idea that many do.

We, as a global majority, are adept at making sound decisions daily. However, our modern communications technology tends to magnify the less wise choices made by a minority. These decisions, often overrepresented in the news cycle, might seem more prevalent than they truly are. This skewed representation leads to a misconception that more people deny global warming than is actually the case. It suggests a significant scientific divide over human contributions to global warming, even though the consensus is largely in agreement.

This disproportionate focus on divergent views gives undue prominence to the few scientists with differing opinions on global warming while overshadowing the majority consensus. The scientific understanding of global warming is comprehensive; the real debate lies in determining our course of action.

The solutions will enrich all

Solving global warming is a complex challenge that will inevitably impact our economies, creating new winners and losers in the process. While we all aspire to be on the winning side, it's crucial to strive for solutions that offer mutual benefits. In the short term, this transition may indeed create disparities, but the long-term prospects promise a richer and healthier life for everyone.

The rewards of tackling global warming extend beyond mere economic benefits. We're looking at a cleaner environment, a brighter future for our children, and a positive legacy left by a generation that not only recognized a significant problem but also took decisive action to address it. Our efforts will enhance our role as responsible stewards of this planet, ensuring the well-being of countless other species that share our home.

The transition to alternative energy sources like solar, wind, and safe nuclear technologies is not just an environmental necessity; it's also an economic opportunity. This shift has the potential to generate millions of new jobs, particularly important in an era where automation and machines threaten traditional employment. Our youth can look forward to careers in these emergent industries, while experts from sectors like oil and gas can apply their valuable process knowledge in these new contexts.

The impacts are manageable

The energy transition necessary to address global warming is set to create new geopolitical realignments worldwide. Oil-rich nations face a potential decline in wealth as the world pivots away from fossil fuels, the primary drivers of global warming. While the negative impacts of this shift can be overstated, history has shown our ability to undergo major transitions without societal collapse. Many leading oil and gas producers are already adapting, pivoting towards new energy industries. Their existing physical, economic, and regulatory infrastructures around oil and gas provide a unique advantage in embracing these emerging sectors.

The transition for these nations is not just a challenge but also an opportunity. The infrastructural and regulatory frameworks established for the oil and gas sector can be repurposed or adapted to support new, sustainable energy industries. This adaptability demonstrates the potential for a smooth transition, mitigating the economic risks traditionally associated with dependency on fossil fuels.

Equally important are the changes required in other major areas contributing to global warming, such as agriculture. Modifying agricultural practices to mitigate climate change will significantly impact the predominantly small, family-run farming enterprises. While these changes are not minor, the consequences of inaction pose a greater threat. Proactive adaptation is essential to safeguard these businesses against the more severe effects of unchecked global warming.

No need for name-calling

This article is not about name-calling, even though it might occasionally seem so. Instead, it focuses on recognising our capacity to set aside differences and self-interest for a greater, common good—a good that promises mutual benefits in the fight against global warming. Choosing self-interest isn't inherently negative. It's a natural part of being human, and we must forgive ourselves and others for occasionally succumbing to it. However, our ability to unite in the face of significant challenges, such as global warming, is a powerful human trait, one that we must embrace.

As mentioned earlier, our opinions on various subjects, including climate change, evolve over time. We oscillate between altruistic and egotistical thoughts, using our knowledge and decision-making skills to determine which thoughts to act upon. While we strive for wise altruism, we often find ourselves swayed by self-interest. The key is not to despair but to rise again and contribute positively to solutions, especially in critical matters like global warming.

Now what?

Unchecked, global warming threatens catastrophic consequences for us all. In this collective battle, connecting with our better selves brings us closer to overcoming this immense challenge. It's essential to acknowledge that there will always be doubters and deniers. Rather than demonising them, we can view them as integral to our vigilance. Their skepticism can serve to sharpen our focus and decision-making in this fight.

Recognise the power you wield in this issue. Leave the petty politicisation to those that are yet to realise it is a ploy for people seeking attention and influence. Focus instead on the actions you can take as a consumer. You have the power to pull corporations into producing sustainably produced products and services, and the power to push governments into action on climate-friendly policies. You the consumer are king, start acting as one.